Ok, here is my theory. March in Maine means one thing. Sea Run Brown Trout. Now, I have noticed a cycle to the Stone Fly hatches and I think I finally figured out the puzzle. Like most things, it is fairly simple. Since we are talking about tidal waters, we are of course talking about high and low tides. So, the tide goes out and all of the rocks are exposed to the warmth of the sunlight for 5 hours or so. Then the tide comes back in and submerges the rock beds again. This incoming tide cycle triggers a good hatch, because all of the bugs that would have hatched over a 5-6 hour period, begin to hatch all at once. Now, with that being said, it is safe to assume that when a major hatch traspires the trout inevitably start feeding. This theory is the only thing that explains the lack of Stone Flies during the outgoing tide and the over abundance of stone flies during the initial stages of the incoming tide. I am not a biologist, so this is just one opinion from a guy who really has no credentials to even give an opinion. But, it makes sense to me and I have been catching fish in the tidal waters by following this theory. I caught the trout in this picture on an Adams Parachute Fly. We all know that the Adams Fly is a versatile fly and represents nearly anything and everything. The picture of the fly that you see is one of the thousands of stone flies that was actually hatching during the incoming tide. They varied in color. Some were light and some were dark, but they were all relatively large in size. It was awesome catching this fish becauseit was nasty on the river. Cold and windy. My feet were cold and the guides on my rod were full of ice. I paid my dues and put in a few hours nymphing. I got so cold that I went to the car to warm up, and boy was I tempted to call it a day. I convinced myself to get back out on the river for a few more casts. So, I walked out to the rising waters edge and stood in one spot and watched the stone flies funnel down a deepening trout run. Then I saw the slurp. A brown tried to sneak a bug off the surface without being seen. Unfortunately for him, he did not go unseen. I checked my guides, checked my line and checked my fly. I knew I only had one shot at this fish and I was not going to blow it with a sloppy cast and/or a bad drift. I false casted twice and dropped the fly in the zone. Nothing happened. Again, nothing happened. @#$#@, I must have spooked him. I casted a third time and the fly was in great shape. It drifted perfectly through the shallows, calmly over the riffles and effortlessly through the deeper section of the … WHAM! He ate it. I brought him in slowly and my buddy Leo was kind enough to take a photo. Leo and I both agreed that the big Stone Fly hatch was a result of the tidal theory. We fished a little longer, told some fish stories, swapped some secret holes and then called it a day. So, when your flyfishing for Sea Run Browns in tidal waters get close to the fresh water run during the incoming tide and throw big stones into the water.
Book
- Alaska
- Guide & Fisherman
- Guiding: Choosing Your Guide And Choosing Your Customer
- Guiding: Do It Yourself With A Guide
- Guiding: Evolution Of A Guide
- Guiding: Freshwater, More Than Meets The Eye
- Guiding: Friends For Life
- Guiding: Know Where You Are
- Guiding: More Than Just A Fisherman
- Guiding: Mystery Of The Fisherman
- Guiding: Payment
- Guiding: Saltwater, A Different World
- Rough Fish
- Fly Fishing For Rough Fish: Why Do It?
- Introduced Rough Fish: The Carps & Other Invasive Species
- Methodology: Gear & Tactics For Pursuing Roughfish On A Fly
- More Roughfish: Bullheads, Whitefish, Goldeye, Burbot & Drum
- Rough Fish Environments: Where To Look For Rough Fish?
- Rough Fish Species: The Suckers
- Rough fish: A Lifetime Of Learning
- Rough Fish: Fishing For Dinosaurs (Gars & Bowfin)
- Rough Fish: What Are They?
- The Hook: Some Common Rough Fish Fly Patterns
- Spey
- Spey: Applications, Where Can You Do It?
- Spey: Atlantic Salmon, A Significant Fish
- Spey: Defined And Demystified
- Spey: Gear, The Nuts And Bolts
- Spey: Lines, They Are That Important
- Spey: Steelhead, New Traditions & A Modern Movement
- Spey: The Energy
- Spey: The Flies
- Spey: The Swing
- Spey: Two Critical Casts
- Striped Bass
- Striped Bass: Fishing Rocky Shorelines
- Striped Bass: Fishing The Beaches
- Striped Bass: Fishing The Flats
- Striped Bass: Fishing The Reefs
- Striped Bass: Fishing Tidal Rivers
- Striped Bass: Flatwing Swing
- Striped Bass: Fly Line Options & Choices
- Striped Bass: Gear, The Nuts & Bolts
- Striped Bass: Migration Patterns
- Striped Bass: What They Eat
- The Art Of Escape
- Fly Fishing: A Natural Drug
- Fly Fishing: A Validation Of Freedom
- Fly Fishing: Don’t Fight The Current
- Fly Fishing: It Is What It Is
- Fly Fishing: Socialization For Asocial Individuals
- Fly Fishing: The Allure Of The Fish
- Fly Fishing: The Art Of Escape
- Fly Fishing: The Simplicity Of It All
- Fly Fishing: Time Flies
- Fly Fishing: Times You Remember & Try To Forget
I just talked to greg-b and he emailed this article to Mike Holt at Flyfishing Only. They seem to agree that the fly in the photo is a Mayfly. What do you think? Stone or Mayfly?
Your idea may have some merit,
Have you considered finding out for real?
Whether you are a biologist or not (I’m a bio-student, but I feel that most fisherman are biologists in many senses but are too modest or whatever to say so or realize it).
There are a few things you can do to prove or even disprove yourself on this idea. But the cool thing that usually happens is that you’ll discover something completely different, a new “truth” so to speak, as science or biology is mainly interested in Truth.
I just moved to Maine myself (Kittery, actually), and Sea-run Browns and Brookies are the foremost creatures of interest for me,…not because I like biology, but ’cause I love the fish, the scene, and the moments.
When I’m on the water this season I’ll always keep your idea in mind. If I ever discover anything conclusive I’ll be sure to try and post it back to you on this forum.
Cool concept,
Take care,
-Jave
I like your observation,….it’s seriously intriguing. I can think of several alternate ideas that fit the scenario. This could be fun to prove for real. You should consider doing it !
-Jave